From Q Notes:
Whether one is
celebrating Hanukkah or Christmas in the United States, there is one
image that is front and center: the family. On Facebook, friends who
celebrate Hanukkah downloaded several images of their children with
their respective grandparents around a lighted menorah. Meanwhile, the
Christmas celebrants download images of their children around Christmas
trees large and small, multi-colored or in thematic splendor. In the
holiday season, across the faiths, we become a nation that celebrates
mom, a dad and a child or children, with or without dogs and cats
included in the folderol.
What is unique in this years assault of “traditional American family”
tableaus is this breaking news of the Supreme Court of the United
States (SCOTUS) hearing cases regarding the Defense of Marriage Act
(DOMA) and California’s Proposition 8. Both DOMA and Prop 8 attempted to
limit marriage as being between one man and one woman, with no chance
of any two parents who were of the same-sex, questioning, bisexual or
transgender allowed to obtain a marriage license. In this bleak wintry
season, hope springs anew for LGBTQ parents. Along with SCOTUS,
marriages between LGBTQ people are taking place in Washington state,
Maryland and Maine, with rumblings from other states where state leaders
are interested in marriage equality.
In this new day and age, lesbian and gays are coming to the
realization that they can now partake in what has been off-limits to
them prior to this: a fuller embrace of the American dream. The dawning
awareness was captured in the LOGO-TV show, “The Baby Wait,” in which
one soon-to-be gay dad uttered (with a sense of awe) these words: “When I
came out to my parents, I never thought I would be able to marry or be
able to raise my own child. Now, I can do both in my lifetime!” In other
words, LGBTQ people are now entering the realm of marrying and
parenting that was solely the domain of straight people. And, this is
being done so no longer as an open act of protest outside the bounds of
the law, but being done legitimately and legally. Living in the dawning
of this new day and age, there are cautionary notes: what do we, as
LGBTQ people, bring to a traditional understanding of marriage and
raising children? Likewise, what traditional ways of being “family” in
the American narrative do we want to borrow? Do we want to live “for
better or for worse, richer or poorer” with one steady other or is there
room for an open relationship? Or, for a steady third person in a
relationship? These, and other questions, will need to be explored,
negotiated, agreed upon, and open for more study in the days, months and
years to come.
Nevertheless, as many of us go forward in other states to get our
marriage licenses, get married, adopt children, we do so because of
those who fought and died to make this day a reality. It is simply
amazing to be part of a social movement that is moving forward with
great alacrity. Along the way, many of us will receive the blessings of a
religious community in the presence of family, friends, wedding
planners…soon followed by baby showers, purchase of minivans, dogs,
cats, lighting of the menorah and tableaus of the family around
Christmas trees. Happy holidays to us all. : :